Pet Toys

Skip to results list

Filters

21 items
Column grid

Active filters:

Column grid

Filter

Active filters:

  • Meow Pak

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Meow Pak

    $39.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • 15" Kick Stix - (4 Pack)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    15" Kick Stix - (4 Pack)

    $34.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • 15" Kick Stix - (2 Pack)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    15" Kick Stix - (2 Pack)

    $18.79 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Electric Flopping Fish Kicker | Organic Catnip Infused

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Electric Flopping Fish Kicker | Organic Catnip Infused

    $15.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Holiday - 11" Stix (2 Pack)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Holiday - 11" Stix (2 Pack)

    $14.49 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • CLAW-tastic Stix - 15"

    Kitty Kick Stix

    CLAW-tastic Stix - 15"

    $12.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • 10" x 10" Large Cat Grass Tray Refill Pack

    Mom’s Indoor Cat

    10" x 10" Large Cat Grass Tray Refill Pack

    $12.00 USD

    FREE SHIPPING!

    Core Standards
    • Refillable
    • Women-Owned
    • Organic
    Certifications
  • 15" Kick Stix Organic Catnip Cat Toy

    Kitty Kick Stix

    15" Kick Stix Organic Catnip Cat Toy

    $10.79 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Fresh Catnip Jar (Ultra Potent)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Fresh Catnip Jar (Ultra Potent)

    $9.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Catnip Fish Kicker - Salmon

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Catnip Fish Kicker - Salmon

    $9.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Cat Scratcher Pad Cardboard (Reversible)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Cat Scratcher Pad Cardboard (Reversible)

    $9.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Plush Catnip Fish Kickers

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Plush Catnip Fish Kickers

    $8.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • 11" Kick Stix

    Kitty Kick Stix

    11" Kick Stix

    $8.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Premium Catnip Spray

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Premium Catnip Spray

    $8.79 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Catnip Kicker Pillow

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Catnip Kicker Pillow

    $5.95 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Crinkle Catnip Kicker

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Crinkle Catnip Kicker

    $4.79 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • CrinkleFish Kick Toy - Catnip Filled w/ Bell & Crinkle

    Kitty Kick Stix

    CrinkleFish Kick Toy - Catnip Filled w/ Bell & Crinkle

    $4.29 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Kitty Cuddlers

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Kitty Cuddlers

    $3.49 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • Fresh Catnip (Various Sizes)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Fresh Catnip (Various Sizes)

    $3.49 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications
  • 100% Natural Silvervine Sticks Cat Toy (2 Pack)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    100% Natural Silvervine Sticks Cat Toy (2 Pack)

    $3.49 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    Certifications
  • Catnip Bag (2oz)

    Kitty Kick Stix

    Catnip Bag (2oz)

    $2.89 USD
    Core Standards
    • Organic
    • Gives Back
    • Non-Toxic
    • Small Batch / Handmade
    Certifications

Explore Directory Brands

Discover independent brands reviewed against OtterList's standards for sustainability, ethics, and transparency. These brands aren't yet part of our marketplace, and we don't earn commissions from them. If you find one you love, let them know you discovered them through OtterList!

Awoo Pets

Sustainable dog walking accessories, toys, and enrichment products.

Better Bone

Plant-based dog chews made from renewable materials, not nylon or rawhide.

OTTERLIST BRAND REVIEW